Methylcobalamin vs. Cyanocobalamin

Nearly 20% of adults over the age of 60 are vitamin B12 deficient. Vitamin B12 is synonymous with energy, focus, and overall well-being. While a healthy body relies on sufficient vitamin B12, food sources may be inadequate to meet the required amount. The most common treatment option for vitamin B12 deficiency is supplements. If accompanied by anemia, then injections. But did you know this essential nutrient primarily comes in two forms: methylcobalamin and cyanocobalamin? Although both effectively treat B12 deficiencies, their origins and properties differ markedly. This article looks at the specific attributes of methylcobalamin vs cyanocobalamin. We aim to help you understand methylcobalamin and cyanocobalamin by detailing their structures, absorption, benefits, and safety.

Methylcobalamin vs. Cyanocobalamin

Methylcobalamin and cyanocobalamin are two widely used forms of vitamin B12, each with unique characteristics.

The former is a natural form of B12 and is directly active in the human body, whereas the latter is a synthetic form that the body can convert into active B12.

Despite structural differences, both forms effectively treat vitamin B12 deficiencies.

Concerns about the cyanide content in cyanocobalamin are unfounded, as the amount is minimal and considered safe by scientists.

Both forms share similar recommended intake levels and health benefits, although some researchers favor cyanocobalamin due to its stability and lower cost.

Chemical Structure

Both cyanocobalamin and methylcobalamin share a core structure:

A central cobalt ion
Surrounded by a corrin ring (similar to heme in red blood cells)

The key difference lies in the molecule attached to the cobalt ion:

Methylcobalamin: Has a methyl group (CH₃) attached
Cyanocobalamin: Has a cyanide molecule (CN^-) attached

Health Benefits

Both methylcobalamin and cyanocobalamin combat vitamin B12 deficiencies and offer additional health benefits:

Deficiency correction:

Methylcobalamin: Studies show normalization of B12 levels within two months in B12-deficient individuals.
Cyanocobalamin: Effective in raising B12 levels in people with pernicious anemia after three months of supplementation.

Neurological support:

Diabetic neuropathy: A review of seven studies suggests both forms can reduce symptoms in diabetic neuropathy patients.
Neuroprotective potential: Animal studies hint at potential benefits for nervous system conditions with both forms.
Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS): Methylcobalamin may treat ALS symptoms by decreasing homocysteine levels, a neurotoxic amino acid. In a 16-week trial, newly diagnosed ALS patients taking 50 mg of methylcobalamin experienced a 43% reduction in disease progression, though further research is needed.

Beyond addressing deficiencies, both methylcobalamin and cyanocobalamin offer promising support for nerve health.

Expert-recommended Read: Can Vitamin D And B12 Deficiency Occur Together?

Read Here

Natural vs. Synthetic

Choosing the right B12 supplement depends on your needs. Here's a quick comparison of methylcobalamin (the natural form) and cyanocobalamin (the synthetic option):

Methylcobalamin

Naturally occurring form, found in animal-based foods such as meat, fish, eggs, and dairy
Considered the "active" form and is readily usable by the body

Cyanocobalamin

Synthetically produced and not naturally occurring
More stable and cost-effective to produce
Converted by the body into active forms like methylcobalamin or adenosylcobalamin

Absorption And Bioavailability

Methylcobalamin and cyanocobalamin differ in their absorption and retention in the body. Research suggests varying levels of absorption between the two forms:

Absorption rates: Studies indicate that cyanocobalamin may be absorbed slightly better than methylcobalamin. For instance, one study found that approximately 49% of a 1-mcg dose of cyanocobalamin was absorbed, compared to 44% of methylcobalamin.
Retention in the body: Research has shown that methylcobalamin may retain better in the body than cyanocobalamin. One study observed that approximately three times as much cyanocobalamin was excreted through urine, suggesting lower retention than methylcobalamin.
Bioavailability considerations: While some studies suggest differences in absorption rates, others indicate that these variations may not be significant. Age and genetic differences could influence the absorption.

Overall, evidence suggests differences in absorption and retention between methylcobalamin and cyanocobalamin.

However, further research can help fully understand these dynamics, especially in diverse populations and under varying health conditions.

Efficacy In Treating Vitamin B12 Deficiency

Research on people on a vegan diet has shown that cyanocobalamin and methylcobalamin are both helpful in addressing vitamin B12 deficiency.

According to the study, cyanocobalamin was more effective in maintaining healthy levels of serum vitamin B12 (called holotranscobalamin) than methylcobalamin.

Which Form Of Vitamin B12 Is Best?

There isn't a single "best" form of vitamin B12 for everyone. The two most common forms are cyanocobalamin and methylcobalamin.

Methylcobalamin is naturally found in animal products and some supplements. Methylcobalamin might be preferable for people with absorption issues or certain medical conditions like pernicious anemia.
Cyanocobalamin is very stable, affordable, and widely available in supplements. Studies suggest cyanocobalamin may be more effective, especially for vegans, in maintaining B12 levels.

Choosing the proper form depends on factors like:

Your overall health: If you have absorption problems or specific medical conditions, methylcobalamin might be better.
Your diet: Vegans might benefit more from cyanocobalamin due to its potential for maintaining B12 levels.

What Is The Safest B12 To Take?

Regarding safety, there's no clear winner between cyanocobalamin and methylcobalamin, the two most common forms of B12 supplements. Both are considered very safe for most people at recommended doses.

Cyanocobalamin contains a small amount of cyanide, but it is not considered to be harmful. Our body easily converts it into harmless compounds. Similarly, methylcobalamin hasn't shown any safety concerns at recommended intake levels.

Here are the two things that may be necessary for optimal safety:

Regardless of the form you choose, sticking to recommended dosages is crucial.
Even safe forms of B12 can cause side effects if taken in very high amounts.

Additionally, if you have any pre-existing health conditions, talk to your doctor before starting B12 supplements.

Comparison Table: Methylcobalamin vs. Cyanocobalamin

Feature	Methylcobalamin	Cyanocobalamin
Type	Natural form, active in the body	Synthetic form, converted to active B12
Source	Found in animal-based foods (meat, fish, eggs, dairy)	Synthetically produced, not naturally occurring
Cost	Generally more expensive	More stable and cost-effective
Absorption Rate	Approximately 44% of a 1-mcg dose absorbed	Approximately 49% of a 1-mcg dose absorbed
Retention	Better retained in the body	Higher excretion in urine, suggesting lower retention
Health Benefits	Effective for deficiency correction, neurological support, potential ALS treatment	Effective for deficiency correction, neurological support
Safety	Safe and naturally occurring	Contains minimal, safe levels of cyanide
Recommended For	People with absorption issues or specific medical conditions	Vegans and those seeking affordable options

Who Needs Vitamin B12 Supplements?

Vitamin B12 supplements are a good idea for people who struggle to get enough B12 from their diet. Here are some groups that might benefit:

Vegetarians and vegans: B12 is mainly present in animal products, so their diets might lack it.
Older adults: B12 absorption diminishes with age. Therefore, supplements might be beneficial.
People having digestive problems: Certain conditions like Crohn's disease could affect the uptake of B12.
Those on some medications: Supplements may be necessary due to interference with absorption by certain drugs.
Patients with pernicious anemia: This condition stops the body from absorbing vitamin B12; hence, lifelong supplementation becomes necessary.

Is It Safe To Take Methylcobalamin Daily?

Studies exploring daily methylcobalamin use in diabetic patients show promise. This natural form of B12 appears safe and may improve nerve pain (diabetic neuropathy) and heart health at doses of 500 mcg three times a day or 1,500 mcg daily.

Bottomline: Methylcobalamin vs. Cyanocobalamin - Which Is Better For Me?

The optimal B12 supplement (methylcobalamin or cyanocobalamin) depends on individual factors.

Absorption issues or certain medical conditions might favor methylcobalamin, the natural form.

Conversely, cyanocobalamin, the synthetic option, may be suitable for maintaining B12 levels in those with dietary restrictions.

Selecting the most appropriate form and dosage for individual needs requires considering overall health and dietary habits and consulting a healthcare professional.